Praiseworthy Competition with One’s Ancestors – Columbus, Indiana Architecture Depository

The Time-Life View (styled after a 1950s Time Life cover featuring Columbus)

Exhibition Void Level 3 – North Christian Church and Miller House (Eero Saarinen)

Creating a Lexicon from Columbus' Material History

Longitudinal Section through new depository and Eero Saarinen's Irwin Union Bank

Horizontal Void turns Vertical

Ground Floor Plan - A dialogue with architectural ancestors

Fifth and Washington - the Design Axes of Columbus

Site Model showing Dan Kiley's original landscape design dropped a level connecting the buildings

Sectional Model of Tower

Kiley's Landscape Recontextualized

Sentinel of Columbus' architectural history

Framing History and Providing Direction/Knowledge

Conceptual Diagrams

Praiseworthy Competition with One’s Ancestors – DSGN5200 – Thesis · 2011-2012 · Advisors: Scott Ruff, Kentaro Tsubaki, RA, Elizabeth Burns Gamard · Outstanding Thesis Award 2012

Twentieth-century philosophy was driven by either/or: Modernism with the abstract and pragmatic, Postmodernism with the material and poetic. Either/or is no longer sufficient. Architecture necessitates a both/and condition, bringing together the abstract and material, the pragmatic and poetic, and the object and field into a cohesive whole creating dialogue with context and disseminating meaning.

In Columbus, Indiana this both/and proposition exists through the patronage of J. Irwin Miller. It is a belief that architecture “reflects what a city thinks about itself and what it aims to be”. Columbus’ Modernism responds to previous generations, bringing together pragmatic and poetic. This thesis aspires to create an architecture depository, a record of Columbus’ material history. In combining Eero Saarinen’s Irwin Union Bank with a pragmatic-poetic addition, the project engages in praiseworthy competition with it’s architectural ancestors.

“A good life is one led in praiseworthy competition with one’s ancestors. The best response to the gifts we receive from previous generations is to create something of lasting value in our own time and in our own way for future generations.” — J. Irwin Miller

Click here for My PechaKucha about Lessons Learned from Columbus – PechaKucha Night Chicago, Volume 33

Download Project Sheet

(Visited 573 times, 1 visits today)